Saturday, November 14, 2026

Bound collections of magazine stories

I have a couple of examples of books that are bound copies of stories from the Strand Magazine - one being the bound copies of the Return stories, and a similar bound copy of the Hound of the Baskervilles from the Strand.

Now I have a more Doylean example, and I'm intrigued. I purchased it from Second Story books in Dupont Circle/Rockville.

The book was listed as titled "A Conan Doyle Pot-Pourri", bound by S. J. Robinson. Octavo, 31 parts, taken from various magazines and bound as one. 

What are the stories? Well the good S.J. Robinson typed up a wonderful Table of Contents. All works were taken from three magazines: Strand, Pearsons and Windsor. 

A Voice of Science (1891) ; An Alpine Pass on Ski (1894) ; Life on a Greenland Whaler (1897) ; Tales of the High Seas - The Governor of St Kitts (1897) ; The Two Barques (1897) ; TheVoyage of Copley Banks.(1897) ; The Striped Chest (1897) ; A Shadow Before (1890) ; Retirement of Sr. Lambert (1898) ; The Croxley Master, Parts I, II, II (1899) ; A Glimpse of the Army (1900) ; Strange Stories from Life - The Holocaust of Manor Place (1901) ; The Love Affair of George Vincent (1901) ; The Debatable Case of Mrs. Emsley (1901) ; A British Commando (1901) ; The Silver Mirror (1908) ; Bendy's Sermon (1909) ; The Lord of Falconbridge (1909) ; Some Recollections of Sport (1909) ; Terror of Blue John Gap (1910) ; The Marriage of the Brigadier (1910) ; One Crowded Hour (1911) ; How it Happened (1913) ; Horror of the Heights (1913) ; Danger (1914) ; Three of them (1918) ; The Fall of Lord Barrymore (1917) ; An Outing in Wartime (1915) ; Stranger than Fiction (1915) ; The Prisoner's Defence (1916) ; Toboganning and Ski Running (1897). 

The bound volume includes a type-written letter signed by Robinson, dated 1976. This outlines his motivation in gathering these stories into a single volume.

Short stories.
During the late nineteenth and early twentieth centuries many well-known authors contributed fiction in the form of short stories to periodicals and especially to popular monthly magazines. 
The short stories could form a related series published in consecutive monthly numbers of the magazine, or they could be unrelated stories published from time to time, not necessarily in the same magazine, and sometimes with long intervals between their appearance. 
The portion of the magazines in which the stories appeared were never bound up and issued as a whole to form a book. The related stories usually were published in book form shortly after the publication of the last story in the magazine. The unrelated stories were published in book form when a publisher and author arranged and agreed to do so, and there are cases where this occurred several years after the appearance of the last story in a magazine ; and as often as not by a published other than that of the magazine stories.
The first appearance of the stories in book form is accepted as the first edition of the author's work. It is important to observe that the magazine story was the first sight the author had of his work in print so it could be considered the ultimate authority for the text, especially when the magazine shows an earlier state. 
Furthermore, most of the magazine stories were profusely where the first editions were not illustrated at all, or if they were - with fewer illustrations. Some magazine stories used illustrations different from those in the book, or by different artists. Other magazine stories were illustrated by a friend of the author's or under his guidance and thus were material to a fuller knowledge of what the author had in mind.
This volume contains a number of stories by Sir Arthur Conan Doyle contributed to popular illustrated monthly magazines in the period 1891 to 1916. The stories are illustrated throughout by well known artists of the day. Where the stories were collected in book form they were not illustrated.
S.J. Robinson, 14 February 1976

Second Story books noted that "According to the introductory note, Robinson believed that, because Doyle's works often showed up in magazines before being written into books, the magazine versions were the "ultimate authority" of those works. This belief is likely a large contributing factor behind his motivation to create the Pot-Pourri. He also lamented the lack of illustrations in book form over magazines. As such, the Pot-Pourri is likely a one-of-a-kind copy.".

I'd like to know more about this person who compiled this volume. There is an ex-libris sticker to front pastedown. What's remarkable is that this sticker is a photograph of Sydney John Robinson, showing him with his beloved books. I'd like some guidance on Sydney's trousers - are they knickerbockers? Or plus-fours?


In the rear pastedown is an owners stamp, with additional handwritten note: "Collected and bound by S.J. Robinson, 57 Orchard Crescent, Enfield, Middlesex".

OK so we now know that Sydney John Robinson was living in the greater London area in the 1970s, and probably bound books for himself. I am frustrated to say that I haven't found any obvious biographical information about S.J. Robinson. I checked into other books currently for sale owned by Robinson - there are about a dozen but none of those are one-off or custom bound volumes. He also does not appear to have been a Sherlockian (or at least one who published).

I will keep searching, but if anyone has information on Sydney John Robinson of London in the 1970s, I'd be grateful to hear from you.


I went back to check on my other two bound copies to see whether they had any distinguishing features that gave a clue to who bound them. My assumption has been this type of bound magazine collection were collated close to the time the magazines appeared. 

Both of my other books certainly 'appear' older even though they are not connected to one another. Both have the title in hold gilt on the cloth spine.

One of the two volumes - the Return - does have a bookbinder stamp on the front pastedown:

J. S. WILSON & SON | Bookbinders, Map Mounters, &c., | 5 Bene’t Street, CAMBRIDGE

This doesn't help me easily identify when the book was published, as the business was established in 1830 and is an ongoing concern. The address proved useful though, taking a deep dive into British newspapers, the business was operated there at least from 1891 and seems to have departed that address (5 Bene't Street) around 1932 when one of the Wilson proprietors died. So that bound copy of Return I have could well have been bound shortly after publication.






No comments:

Post a Comment

Bound collections of magazine stories

I have a couple of examples of books that are bound copies of stories from the Strand Magazine - one being the bound copies of the Return st...