Friday, November 20, 2026

The Passing Acquaintances of Arthur Conan Doyle - Part 6: Edgar Tozer

The latest Passengers' Log (PL), from the Sydney Passengers, has arrived in the mail - it's always wonderful to receive, and as always has some excellent articles. 

This issue has the latest article in my slow-walk series shining a light on the personalities that ACD mentions in his book on visiting Australia/NZ titled 'Wanderings of a Spiritualist'. Part 6 describes the first person Doyle mentions in theMelbourne, where he arrived from Adelaide. 

As always, once my articles are published I provide the submitted (not final) version of the article on my blog. It also gives me a chance to add one or two things that didn't survive the editorial process.


The Passing Acquaintances of Arthur Conan Doyle - Part 6: Edgar Tozer
Matthew D. Hall

During his tour of Australia and New Zealand, Sir Arthur Conan Doyle (ACD) interacted with many people, and spoke to tens of thousands in his audiences. Yet ACD’s book describing the tour, ‘The Wanderings of a Spiritualist’, mentions relatively few people that he met by name. {1} This article is the fifth in a series that shines a light on those people ACD met on his visit. Why did ACD choose to mention those that he did (and not others)? Who were these Australians? The biosketches presented aim to address these questions, and point to more detailed resources. 

The sixth identity that Doyle described spending time with, and the first after his arrival in Melbourne, was Edgar Tozer (1868-1949). An excellent summary of Doyle’s spiritualist journey in Australia is described in Let the Dead Speak - Spiritualism in Australia, winner of a 2026 ACD Society ‘Doylean Honor for Scholarly Writing’. {2}

Doyle arrived by train from Adelaide at Spencer Street Station on 1st October, and was greeted by followers including Tozer. The family headed to the Menzies Hotel for the first few days before establishing in a flat in the Grand, and there the Doyles lived for five weeks. The day after arriving, ACD, his wife, and personal secretary Major Wood attended the VFL Grand Final at the Melbourne Cricket Ground to see Richmond win their first premiership. {3}

From a Spiritualist point of view, Doyle was frustrated by the media in Melbourne which "had done their best to make the soil stony for me." Nevertheless he found a large Spiritualist following:  "I began at once to endeavour to find out the conditions of local Spiritualism, and had a long conversation with Mr. Tozer, the chairman of the movement, a slow-talking, steady-eyed man, of the type that gets a grip and does not easily let go. After explaining the general situation, which needs some explanation as it is full of currents and cross-currents caused by individual schisms and secessions, he told me in his gentle, earnest way some of his own experiences in his home circle which corroborate much which I have heard elsewhere. He has run a rescue circle for the instruction of the lower spirits who are so material that they can be reached more easily by humanity than by the higher angels. The details he gave me were almost the same as those given by Mr. MacFarlane of Southsea who had a similar circle of which Mr. Tozer had certainly never heard." 

Doyle then gave over a number of paragraphs in his book to explain the method of the rescue circle. In brief, a medium is possessed by a 'lower spirit' that requires reform, and "is often very violent, the medium having to be held down and using rough language." A 'wise spirit control' reasons with the spirit, helping it recognize it errant ways, and make their way from earth to the next plane. When Xenophon reviewed The Wanderings of a Spiritualist upon its publication in 1921, they perhaps captured the feelings of most people when they stated "For the reader with a sense of humor the exploits of Mr. Tozer, of Melbourne, will be very acceptable." {4}


Photographic portrait of Edgar Tozer, from The world's greatest mysteries by Charles Neil, Melbourne, 1936.

Edgar Tozer (1868–1949) was a prominent figure in early 20th-century Australian Spiritualism. He served as the president of the Victorian Spiritualists' Union (VSU) in Melbourne and was described as the "Father of Spiritualism in the Commonwealth of Australia”. {5} Yet finding a photograph of Tozer proved challenging. The portrait photograph shown is from a Spiritualist book The world's greatest mysteries for which Tozer contributed the introduction. {6} The book includes an explanation of how a Spiritualist solved the mystery of who Jack the Ripper was. In his introduction Tozer stated "My spiritual experiences cover a period of over 50 years. For 22 years I conducted spiritual Rescue Classes. During this period I contacted weekly, five spirit entities, and, each week, privately contacted a similar number.”

Tozer was born in the country Victoria town of Talbot in 1868. Tozer gave a talk in 1937 in which he shared that he was the grand-nephew of explorer William John Wills. {7} In 1894, Edgar married Mary Jane Richards in North Melbourne, and records indicate the couple had at least four children, Edgar (1895), Adrian (1898), Donald (1905), and Paul (1911). Edgar's occupation was news agent when he married, and a few later references to his occupation describe Edgar as a 'city business man' and engineer. Tozer's family and business life was balanced with his heavy involvement and activity as a spiritualist.

The first reference to Tozer as a spiritualist appears to be a December 1914 advertisement for spiritualistic services performed in Oddfellows Hall. By 1916 Tozer was mentioned in newspapers as President of the Spiritualistic Society of Victoria, and in 1918 he led a meeting of over 1,400 spiritualists. This was the position and role Tozer held when ACD arrived in Melbourne October 1920.

As ACD described (see above), he met Tozer as part of his tour, and on Saturday 9th October ACD was welcomed by Spiritualistic Churches at the Masonic Hall in Collins St (now demolished), at which he addressed the group. The advertisement indicates that the service included an amateur orchestra performance before, and a welcoming address with provided by Edgar Tozer to both ACD and Lady Conan Doyle who attended with their children. {8} The Age reported that 'Sir Arthur Conan Doyle said it was the first meeting of spiritualists he had addressed since he left England. He could not address them in conventional terms. He could only call them comrades. (Applause.) They were comrades in fighting for God's own truth. According to their teaching they really were the children of a good Father, who had prepared ample reparation for all they had to endure on this side. It was a joy to meet them, and to see that great hall filled by those who were wholly in sympathy with the movement.’

The Doyle clan proceeded on in their travels through Victoria, New Zealand, and Australia, but boomeranged back to Melbourne as their port of departure. On Friday 4th February 1921, the eve of his departure, a farewell event was held at Melbourne Town Hall, over which Edgar Tozer presided, and ACD spoke for 40 minutes. At this event, Tozer presented ACD with 'an address in an Australian Blackwood case'. {9} ACD described the address as an ‘inscription… encased in Australian wood with a silver kangaroo outside and beautiful illuminations within'. Remarkably, the State Library of New South Wales now holds this memento in its collection (PXE 934/no. 1). The photographs confirm Doyle's description, with a wonderful metal kangaroo figurine affixed, Australian flora illustrating the address, and signed by several spiritualists including Edgar Tozer.


This item with a wonderful Australian connection was acquired by the library at the Christie's (London) auction of the Conan Doyle Collection on 19 May 2004. The address appears in the published auction catalogue as item 65.

And with that, the Doyles sailed west from Melbourne. Tozer's Spiritualist work did not cease, nor did his connection to ACD. When 'Wanderings' was published in late 1921, book reviews reacted with disbelief that ACD could believe Tozer's seance activities: 'At a seance Mr. Tozer's body appears to be inhabited by a well-educated Chinaman, an indulgent, smiling spirit, who still talks the funny, abbreviated English-proper to Chinamen on the stage... another occasion 'a terrifying Ghurkha came along, who still thought he was in action, and charged about the circle, upsetting the medium's chair, and only yielding to a mixture of force and persuasion.... Sir Arthur finds no difficulty in believing such phenomena to be genuine'. {10} In August 1930, Tozer advertised that all Spiritual Churches should memorialize ACD's 'transition' (i.e., death) and 'place an empty chair for reception of his spirit'. {11} As late as 1944, Tozer published a letter defending Doyle's spiritualism, stating 'I knew Doyle personally... and can vouch for {his} thorough research and writings as truth’.

Notice to Spiritual Churches upon the death of Arthur Conan Doyle. 

Edgar's wife died in 1940, and Edgar died on 7 Aug 1948. As a spiritualist he did not have a ‘funeral’, he had a 'transition service'. The resting place of Edgar’s remains have not been identified.

References

1. I am using the 1988 reprint published by Ronin Publishing, Inc. Berkeley CA.

2.  Andrew Singleton and Matt Tomlinson, Let the Dead Speak - Spiritualism in Australia, Manchester University Press, 2025, see Appendix B.

3.  ‘Richmond win their first league premiership pennant’, The Herald (Melbourne), 2 Oct 1920 

4.  Xenophon, Conan Doyle's Australian Wanderings, The Herald (Melbourne), 19 Nov 1921.

5.  Psychic Observer, New York, USA, Aug 10 1941.

6.  Charles Neil, The world's greatest mysteries, 1936, Melbourne.

7.  ‘Linked with explorers’, The Argus (Melbourne), 20 Nov 1937.

8.   The Age (Melbourne), Sat 9 Oct 1920.

9.  Sir A. Conan Doyle, The Argus (Melbourne), 5 Feb 1921.

10.  Xenophon, Conan Doyle's Australian Wanderings, The Herald (Melbourne), 19 Nov 1921.

11.  The Age (Melbourne), 23 Aug 1930.


Saturday, November 14, 2026

Bound collections of magazine stories

I have a couple of examples of books that are bound copies of stories from the Strand Magazine - one being the bound copies of the Return stories, and a similar bound copy of the Hound of the Baskervilles from the Strand.

Now I have a more Doylean example, and I'm intrigued. I purchased it from Second Story books in Dupont Circle/Rockville.

The book was listed as titled "A Conan Doyle Pot-Pourri", bound by S. J. Robinson. Octavo, 31 parts, taken from various magazines and bound as one. 

What are the stories? Well the good S.J. Robinson typed up a wonderful Table of Contents. All works were taken from three magazines: Strand, Pearsons and Windsor. 

A Voice of Science (1891) ; An Alpine Pass on Ski (1894) ; Life on a Greenland Whaler (1897) ; Tales of the High Seas - The Governor of St Kitts (1897) ; The Two Barques (1897) ; TheVoyage of Copley Banks.(1897) ; The Striped Chest (1897) ; A Shadow Before (1890) ; Retirement of Sr. Lambert (1898) ; The Croxley Master, Parts I, II, II (1899) ; A Glimpse of the Army (1900) ; Strange Stories from Life - The Holocaust of Manor Place (1901) ; The Love Affair of George Vincent (1901) ; The Debatable Case of Mrs. Emsley (1901) ; A British Commando (1901) ; The Silver Mirror (1908) ; Bendy's Sermon (1909) ; The Lord of Falconbridge (1909) ; Some Recollections of Sport (1909) ; Terror of Blue John Gap (1910) ; The Marriage of the Brigadier (1910) ; One Crowded Hour (1911) ; How it Happened (1913) ; Horror of the Heights (1913) ; Danger (1914) ; Three of them (1918) ; The Fall of Lord Barrymore (1917) ; An Outing in Wartime (1915) ; Stranger than Fiction (1915) ; The Prisoner's Defence (1916) ; Toboganning and Ski Running (1897). 

The bound volume includes a type-written letter signed by Robinson, dated 1976. This outlines his motivation in gathering these stories into a single volume.

Short stories.
During the late nineteenth and early twentieth centuries many well-known authors contributed fiction in the form of short stories to periodicals and especially to popular monthly magazines. 
The short stories could form a related series published in consecutive monthly numbers of the magazine, or they could be unrelated stories published from time to time, not necessarily in the same magazine, and sometimes with long intervals between their appearance. 
The portion of the magazines in which the stories appeared were never bound up and issued as a whole to form a book. The related stories usually were published in book form shortly after the publication of the last story in the magazine. The unrelated stories were published in book form when a publisher and author arranged and agreed to do so, and there are cases where this occurred several years after the appearance of the last story in a magazine ; and as often as not by a published other than that of the magazine stories.
The first appearance of the stories in book form is accepted as the first edition of the author's work. It is important to observe that the magazine story was the first sight the author had of his work in print so it could be considered the ultimate authority for the text, especially when the magazine shows an earlier state. 
Furthermore, most of the magazine stories were profusely where the first editions were not illustrated at all, or if they were - with fewer illustrations. Some magazine stories used illustrations different from those in the book, or by different artists. Other magazine stories were illustrated by a friend of the author's or under his guidance and thus were material to a fuller knowledge of what the author had in mind.
This volume contains a number of stories by Sir Arthur Conan Doyle contributed to popular illustrated monthly magazines in the period 1891 to 1916. The stories are illustrated throughout by well known artists of the day. Where the stories were collected in book form they were not illustrated.
S.J. Robinson, 14 February 1976

Second Story books noted that "According to the introductory note, Robinson believed that, because Doyle's works often showed up in magazines before being written into books, the magazine versions were the "ultimate authority" of those works. This belief is likely a large contributing factor behind his motivation to create the Pot-Pourri. He also lamented the lack of illustrations in book form over magazines. As such, the Pot-Pourri is likely a one-of-a-kind copy.".

I'd like to know more about this person who compiled this volume. There is an ex-libris sticker to front pastedown. What's remarkable is that this sticker is a photograph of Sydney John Robinson, showing him with his beloved books. I'd like some guidance on Sydney's trousers - are they knickerbockers? Or plus-fours?


In the rear pastedown is an owners stamp, with additional handwritten note: "Collected and bound by S.J. Robinson, 57 Orchard Crescent, Enfield, Middlesex".

OK so we now know that Sydney John Robinson was living in the greater London area in the 1970s, and probably bound books for himself. I am frustrated to say that I haven't found any obvious biographical information about S.J. Robinson. I checked into other books currently for sale owned by Robinson - there are about a dozen but none of those are one-off or custom bound volumes. He also does not appear to have been a Sherlockian (or at least one who published).

I will keep searching, but if anyone has information on Sydney John Robinson of London in the 1970s, I'd be grateful to hear from you.


I went back to check on my other two bound copies to see whether they had any distinguishing features that gave a clue to who bound them. My assumption has been this type of bound magazine collection were collated close to the time the magazines appeared. 

Both of my other books certainly 'appear' older even though they are not connected to one another. Both have the title in hold gilt on the cloth spine.

One of the two volumes - the Return - does have a bookbinder stamp on the front pastedown:

J. S. WILSON & SON | Bookbinders, Map Mounters, &c., | 5 Bene’t Street, CAMBRIDGE

This doesn't help me easily identify when the book was published, as the business was established in 1830 and is an ongoing concern. The address proved useful though, taking a deep dive into British newspapers, the business was operated there at least from 1891 and seems to have departed that address (5 Bene't Street) around 1932 when one of the Wilson proprietors died. So that bound copy of Return I have could well have been bound shortly after publication.






Sunday, November 8, 2026

Gold Bugs and Restless Fays

Honestly we probably don't need another Dancing Men article, but it's a story that keeps on giving. One element that intrigues me are the accusations of plagiarism against Doyle regarding the Dancing Men - there were only a few, but they did appear in the press. 

A deeper read of the articles reveals that the accusation isn't really plagiarism - it's a recognition that Doyle drew 'deep inspiration' from the plot elements of other stories. 


Barbados Agricultural Reporter
Wednesday, 9 March 1904
Doyle a Plagiarist? 
St. Louis, Mo.,—Donald 0. Fitzmaurice, writing to the Globe Democrat, charges Sir A. Conan Doyle with plagiarizing "The Adventures of the Dancing Men," in Collier's Weekly, from Poe's "Gold Bug." He does not say it is the same language and plot, but the manner in which the mysteries are solved, he says, is the same in both cases. 
After quoting from one of the "Sherlock Holmes" stories, in which the detective deprecates the astuteness of Dupin, Poe's detective in the "Rue Morgue" story, Mr. Fitzmaurice says: "To such a conclusion I Interpose nothing of objection. The particular incident referred to is that to be found in 'The Murders in the Rue Morgue,' when Dupin is represented as conveying to the writer of the story the immediate subject of his thought, and then tracing their development or evolution step by step back to an incident which had occurred a quarter an hour earlier. 
"That it was showy cannot be doubted. That it was superficial is equally plain.
"It is not really difficult to construct a series of inferences each dependent upon its predecessor and each simple in itself. If, after doing so, one simply knocks out all the central inferences and presents the starting point and the conclusion, one may produce a startling though possibly a meretricious effect.' 
"All this, whether in London or Paris, is certainly cheap enough, but it is cheaper in Doyle than in Poe : first, because with Poe it is an inspiration and with Doyle a plagiarism; and second, because while Poe this nonsense is but one manifestation of an ill balanced mind in a story of splendid imaginative power, written by the hand and brain of genius, in Doyle it fits well with other extravagances the same sort. It the plagiarist would plagiarize the best style as well as the poorest thought of the genius he would really be more excusable. But that Doyle does not plagiarze only Poe's poorest thought, the manner in which he makes Sherlock Holmes solve the cipher in 'The Adventures of the Dancing Men' is ample evidence. 
"As to the plagiarism it will never be,  for the proof is too overwhelming. In Poe's strange weird story, 'The Gold Bug,' Legrand tells how he deciphered the cipher writing on the parchment paper which showed the way to the pirate board. After telling how the figure 8 predominated in the cipher, Legrand goes on to say : 'Now in English the letter which most frequently occurs is E. Here, then, we have in the very beginning the ground work for something more than a mere guest. As our predominant character is 8, we will not commence by assuming it is the E of the natural alphabet.' 
"Legrand, with the predominant figure of his script representing the commonest letter of the alphabet, solved the mystery of the hidden treasure. Holmes, with the predominant figure of his script standing for the same letter, solved the mystery of 'Aldthorpe Manor'. Mr. Doyle is evidently being put hard to it to turn out his products fast enough for the money.

So as we see, the charge is not REALLY plagiarism, but it certainly points to Doyle directly adapting a story element from Poe, and weaving it into a Holmes story. Fitzmaurice's letter was written shortly after Dancing Men was published and appeared in the St. Loius Globe-Democrat. His letter received rapid coverage - it was referenced in the New York Times on Christmas Day 1903. This Chicago Tribune headline appeared on December 27, 1903:

Along with articles across the United States, it was also discussed in newspapers in Australia but importantly not the UK.

The voice of reason did counter these accusations. For example, this Feb 1904 piece in the 'Worker' published in Queensland, Australia.

Worker (Brisbane, Qld), Sat 20 Feb 1904 
Conan Doyle is alleged to have cribbed the plot of 'The Dancing Men' from Poe's 'Golden Bug.' Very little resemblance can be traced between the two stories. There is a type of scribbler who is always nosing around and discovering "plagiarisms" where they don't exist. He reminds one of an ill-bred terrier who makes a demonstration at every hole he comes across, under the delusion that he has run a rat to earth. The one good point about the plagiarist-hunter is that no one ever deems it worth while to plagiarise him.

Let's take a look at the code in 'Gold Bug'. The cipher was composed of conventional characters that appear in print, rather than a custom graphical code.


Nevertheless, the accusation is that the solving of the cipher was similar in both stories. The solver Legrand outlines to the narrator the initial steps to solving it:

"Now, in English, the letter which most frequently occurs is e. Afterwards, the succession runs thus: a o i d h n r s t u y c f g l m w b k p q x z. E however predominates so remarkably that an individual sentence of any length is rarely seen, in which it is not the prevailing character. Here, then, we have, in the very beginning, the groundwork for something more than a mere guess... As our predominant character is 8, we will commence by assuming it as the e of the natural alphabet."

In The Dancing Men, Holmes employs a similar strategy. That is the objection of the writer. Were the letter to appear in the UK, the writer might have worried aboot being up on a charge of libel!

The connection was widely recognized - in 1905 the American journalist and poet Arthur Chapman published a well-known pastiche titled 'The Unmasking of Sherlock Holmes' in 'The Critic', which includes the line from Dupin to Holmes "I don't even hold that 'Dancing Men' story against you, in which you made use of a cryptogram that instantly brought up thoughts of 'The Gold Bug'".



A second curious case emerges from the pages of a number of magazines including 'The Boy's Own Paper' in the 1870s and 1880s. 'The Language of the Restless Fays' appeared a number of times in various magazines, and could easily have been seen by Doyle as a young man. A 'fay' is a fairy, elf, or sprite. The text is transcribed undernearth:


The Boy's Own Paper
An Odd Column
The Language of the Restless Fays

Here you have two very well-known verses written in the language of the Restless Fays. It is exactly the same as English, excepting in the form of its letters. The Fays have twenty six distinct positions, one for each letter of the alphabet. P and C, for instance, invariably lie on their backs, though the head of one points to the right and that of the other to the left. E is always seen dancing, with his arms up in the air, and X, not being often needed, sits at his ease. In due time we shall publish a full key to this interesting alphabet, for the benefit of all who wish to correspond in the new language. Meanwhile, who can read the above verses? The first letter is an "L".

Sure enough, the solution and key was ultimately published.


The remarkable similarly of the 'Restless Fays' of thirty years earlier did not go entirely un-noticed after the 'Dancing Men' were published in 1903. In 1910, a short article was published in 'The Bookman' by Lyndon Orr - the pen-name for Harry Thurston Peck (1856-1914). Peck was a Professor of Latin & Literature at Columbia University in New York.

Writing in The Bookman, Orr/Lang wrote (digitized at Hathitrust) :

Now {Dancing Men} was considered a fairly good one compared with the other stories in the same book ; and some credit was given to Sir A. Conan Doyle for the ingenuity of his cryptogram. Not very long ago, however, an eminent surgeon of this city who has, like so many of his profession, a fondness for literature, happened, on a rainy day, to be looking over a bundle of old magazines. Among them was a copy of the first volume of St. Nicholas. In the number for May, 1874 (page 439), there occurs a puzzle given under the title "The Language of the Restless Imps.... {see above}.

The interest of all this comes in when one observes that the "restless imps" of the St. Nicholas magazine for 1874 are precisely the "dancing men" of Sir A. Conan Doyle's story, published just thirty years after. The alphabet has been transposed in most cases, but the "dancing men" are the same, so far as they enter into Sir A. Conan Doyle's narrative. The gentleman who made this discovery took it for granted that some one had suggested (or perhaps sold) the cryptogram to the British writer. He, therefore, wrote a courteous letter to Sir Conan Doyle, pointing out to him that his cryptogram was really three decades old and warning him against the possibility that other aged material might be palmed off to him. In reply came a half-penny post-card which read as follows:

This was not a very satisfactory answer when sent to an eminent member of Sir A. Conan Doyle's own profession. It was curt in tone and was not even provided with sufficient postage to carry it to the gentleman to whom it was addressed, without requiring him to pay for its delivery. Naturally he was somewhat incensed. Therefore, he countered on Sir Arthur by sending him a one cent post-card addressed:

We tell this story simply as it happened, leaving our readers to decide whether the coincidence was pure or impure. But this case of coincidence deserves to be set side by side with Sir A. Conan Doyle's well-known narrative which he calls "A Case of Identity."
Lyndon Orr

I'm not sure Sherlock Holmes believed in coincidences.

Who was the eminent surgeon of New York? Possibly a member of Faculty at Columbia. It is curious that the correspondence was to warn Doyle that someone was offering him previously-published ideas, and with a response so curt. So curt that I suspect it wasn't the first query ACD received on the matter.

As an aside, 1910 was an interesting time for Peck to be publishing letters that point to a potentially sensitive topic. Peck himself was embroiled in the publication of his love-letters by his former secretary as part of a breach-of-promise case in 1910. He was fired from Columbia (even though the case was dismissed) and ultimately died by suicide in 1914.

What can one make of all the multiple accusations of plagiarism and 'inspiration'? Simply that Doyle used what he discovered around him for literary purposes. He found 'tit bits' and wove them into wonderful stories. One wonders whether the range of observations filtered back to Doyle, and whether he cared at all at the recognition in the US of his inspirations.

There are some outstanding discussions of the use of the Cubitt children dancing men, and the inspirations taken from earlier literary sources. To me, the most important articles are those by Thelma Beam and Donny Zaldin that appear in Canadian Holmes (2013), and in the BSI Press facsimile edition of 'Dancing Men'.

Saturday, October 24, 2026

A new edition of the Baker Street File - 2026

I've previously written about The Baker Street File created as a guide for the filming of the Granada series, and its edition published by Calabash Press. The article I wrote was published in the Sherlock Holmes Review, and I interviewed Christopher Roden who first published the Baker Street File. 

The original wasn't created for distribution (it wasn't published), and the Calabash Press edition is now in demand (and therefore expensive).  As part of my aforementioned article I also interviewed Gus Holwerda (a co-host of the Jeremy Brett Sherlock Holmes Podcast). Now as part of their 2026 Brettcon event in England, the Holwerda's have published a facsimile edition of the original Granada Baker Street File. Not just any copy - David Burke had loaned his copy that included his handwritten notes.

This new edition is available at their Etsy store, and mine arrived in the mail today, along with a few other items: the tote bag, a Wessex Press CD recording of a Michael Cox talk, and a special Brettcon 2026 edition of Granada's Greatest Detective by Keith Frankel.


At the bottom of the post I'm including the stock photographs from their Etsy store, along with their narrative. I'm partly doing so for preservation purposes - these things disappear from sites once they are sold out.

The volume is softcover, with a rich red cover, and sized about 6 x 10 inches - that's quite a bit smaller that the original size of the Baker Street File (I show a comparison below). The volume is mainly printed single-side, as was the original. 



Burke's copy included his notes across two pages of the volume. Conveniently, the volume includes a transcription of Burke's notes. Here is an example:

So Watson is the epitome of the best kind of English gentleman: kind, gentle, courteous, impeccably polite and well-behaved, modest, brave, faithful to his friends, gallant to women. He is perhaps different in that he loves adventure and gambling. He is very romantic (especially about women. He is not stuffy. He frequently shares laughter with Holmes. Hot tempered where he feels injustice has been done. He is not stupid, but he represents the reaction of an average intelligence in dealing with an erratic genius.
He is conventional in many of his habits.
What I have tried to bring to the relationship is laughter shared, and an angry impatience with Holmes occasional bad-manners, drug taking and criticism of Watson's writing. This is new.


Here is the 2026 edition (right), alongside a copy of the original Baker Street File (left), this copy was actually used as the source text for the Calabash Edition from 1997 (center). 

The Etsy store description:

At long last, The Baker Street File resurfaces!

Originally distributed to the cast of The Adventures of Sherlock Holmes in 1983, this document was a 72-page, hand-typed, photocopied and stapled pamphlet, created by series producer Michael Cox, associate producer Stuart Doughty and researcher Nicky Cooney, with Michael’s secretary, Carol Brand, tasked with the job of typing it all up.

The Baker Street File was less of a polished tome and more of a working toolkit, made for function rather than form. So we can forgive any spelling errors or mislabeling herein. In fact, in the time it took to reproduce the text inside, we’ve decided to honor what must have been an excruciating undertaking on the part of Carol Brand, and have opted to leave it just as she typed it in 1983.

Speaking to Stuart Doughty recently, he shared that the bulk of the work was done very quickly, stating, “Michael describes the process in the introduction, and that’s how I remember it. We split the stories between the three of us and then, with no great master plan, read them quickly, at home or in the office, and jotted down the quotes in longhand on A4 lined pads. Michael suggested collating them according to subject and I did that, choosing the subject headings and making some order from all the quotations. I think the abbreviations for the stories were copied from the huge, classic annotated Sherlock Holmes volume. The result was typed up, as Michael writes, by Carol, his secretary. (Secretaries then, not PAs!). I checked it through, edited it a bit, and hey presto!” 

The resulting guide, with fewer than 100 copies created, has become the stuff of legend - whispered about at Sherlockian conventions, with pre-owned copies traded in dimly-lit backrooms, and the new class of Jeremy Brett devotees (affectionately referred to as “Brettons”) left wondering how they can obtain one. 

As the unofficial custodians of the Granada series, we at The Jeremy Brett Sherlock Holmes Podcast had the opportunity to meet and interview the actor who portrayed Dr. Watson on the first 13 episodes of the show, Mr. David Burke. David found something in the pages of Doyle’s writing that no previous actor had portrayed. Watson was a deep, caring and intellectual individual, not simply the bumbling biographer who shadowed Holmes, as he’d been so often depicted. Behind those twinkling, slightly mischievous eyes was a true friend full of warmth and sincerity.

When he agreed to speak with us in 2022, we were warmly welcomed by David and his wife, Anna Calder-Marshall, into their idyllic home in the countryside of Kent. What we expected would consume an hour or two turned into lunch, conversations on and off mic, drinking wine under the willow tree, and Anna telling us each to have a go on a rope swing that thrust out over their private pond. A brief encounter with a hero of ours turned into years of keeping in contact and discussing future projects, one being to help David publish a book of original short stories. At some point in the intervening months, David and Anna entrusted us with all of David’s tales as well as his original copy of The Baker Street File, which had a number of handwritten notes and markings that he had found useful when preparing to play the character. A date was arranged for us to travel to England to see the Burkes again whereupon we had planned to surprise the couple with review copies of David’s bound stories and The Baker Street File reprinted. Sadly, David had taken his final bow before we could return.

In the months since, as a tribute to this wonderful man, a new burst of energy began driving these books to completion and the result is Dr. Watson’s Baker Street File, an as-accurate-as-we-can-make-it recreation of David’s personal copy of the File, complete with his hand-written notes and markings in the margins.

This copy of The Baker Street File is as true in format to the original as has even been produced, down to the typewriter font, word and letter spacing and even single-sided printing. We hope that you enjoy referencing it on your own Sherlockian journey and we hope that it honors our friend, David Burke. 

“Here’s to us, and those like us, damn few.”

Friday, October 23, 2026

Watson's Tin Box meeting summary - October 19, 2026

On the third Monday of each month, Watson's Tin Box of Ellicott City meets at Union Jack's in Columbia MD and we gathered October 19 for another great gathering of members. 

As always I took a census of where people were attending from: Columbia MD won the competition for most attendees with six people - we also had visitors from places including: Frederick, Bellcamp, Ellicott City, Silver Spring, Frederick, Gaithersburg, Darnestown Woodbine, Sandy Spring, Washington DC and Baltimore. 

Congratulations to Michael Becker who became a member of WTB with his second visit, and we welcomed first-time visitor, Greg Bodine ! 

The story of the meeting was 'The Adventure of the Retired Colourman'.... but we always start with toasts. 

Tom Hill delivered a toast to The Woman - an original.

Liane Luini contributed her traditional 'second toast'. This month's was written by PJ Sullivan and offered on the Occasion of the Annual Dinner of the Cornish Horrors (RI), 4th November 2023.

A Toast to Dr. Leon Sterndale

by PJ Sullivan


I present to you one Dr. Sterndale,

Whose adventures were storied and many;

Called Leon, his friends would regale – 

Or would, shall we say, had he any. 

For he lived in a manner most solit’ry 

Hunting lions abroad all his life, 

Returning to Cornwall occasion’ly 

To the woman he wished was his wife. 

But sweet Brenda was slain by her brother. 

Roundhay’s wire reached Sterndale in time. 

Abiding his own law – no other – 

He enacted a vengeance sublime. 

The Devil’s Foot Root provided, they say, 

The revenge for which his soul cried. 

The Great Explorer cornered his prey, 

And Tregennis: “My God! How he died!” 

I’ll not recount this whole terrible tale, 

A tragedy steeped in Cornish gore. 

The details – the Horrors – would leave you all pale, 

And possibly you may have heard it before. 

So a toast now to Leon Sterndale 

Who dealt Justice, I’m sure you’ll agree; 

Whom Watson and Holmes would not denounce, 

And nor, I imagine, would we. 

Tom Fahres delivered TWO Haikus. First to The Woman of the evening:

Amberley’s young wife
Believed to be “The Woman”
To Doctor Ernest

Secondly, Tom delivered his traditional Haiku for the story of the month:

Canon’s last story
All of the perps were collared 
And Barker debuts

Next came Announcements

  • Carla Coupe reminded us that the 47th Annual "Saturday With Sherlock Holmes" at the Pratt Library will be held Saturday, November 14th from 10:30 to 1:00. It will be live-streamed at this link.
  • Olivia Millunzi reminded us that the play 'Clue' (based on the movie) will be performed at the Hipodrome, Baltimore on January 23 & 24.
  • Tom Fahres shared a save-the-date of Friday Oct 23, from 4-6pm for the MoCo Maryland Mullusk Masticaters SPODE. Meet at Olney Grille, Olney, Maryland.
  • Kem White would like a recommendation of a local bookbinder please. Are there local bookbinding classes? Please let me know!
  • The next meeting of the Red Circle of Washington DC will be held on Saturday, Novmber 22 - starting by joining a screening of 'The Seven Percent Solution' at the AFI Silver Spring to celebrate the 50th Anniversary of its original release. Afterwards, we can dine at J. Hollinger's - right across the road. The speaker will be Julie McKuras coming from Minnesota, and details can be found at www.redcircledc.org
  • We were reminded that Peter Blau has also announced that tickets are now on sale for Mark Shanahan's popular play "A Sherlock Carol" at the Arts Barn in Gaithersburg.  There will be a  do-it-yourself theater party and Red Circle meeting on Sunday, December 6.  Purchase your own tickets, and the group will then gather somewhere nearby for drinks afterwards. You can purchase your tickets at the Arts Barn web-site.
  • Matt reminded people that there is a Maryland scion WTB members probably haven't visited - Denizens of the Bar of Gold, which meets just over the Bay Bridge on the Eastern Shore of MD. You can learn all about the scion here, and join their mailing list: http://www.homeroomd140.com/invitation_fall_26.html#Index 
  • The 'Baker Street in Baltimore' newsletter has returned after a hiatus - this was started in 2014, and paused during COVID. Now, Liane Luini will publish irregular issues, all of which can be read here.
  • At the recent Six Napoleons of Baltimore 80th Anniversary Dinner, WTB displayed the Evidence Box. We created a printed inventory to share with dinner attendees, and I provided copies to WTB members.
  • Michelle March ended announcements by sharing her 'charm' for this month's story. I'm not always good at adding this - Michelle created small 'Watson's Tin Boxes' for us all, and each month we receive a charm related to the story - this month the charm was a painbrush!






We moved on to the quiz, prepared by Olivia Millunzi. Completeing the quiz prior to the Evidence Box presentation or story discussion really helps separate the wheat from the chaff! 

As always, Michelle March provided some wonderful t-shirt design prizes tied to the evening's story:

Had the blues,
Became green with envy,
Saw red
Too yellow for confrontation
Condemned them to purple rain
All there in black and white
50 shades of Josiah Amberley
(Orange you glad to read the whole thing?)

Joshia Amberley
Tried to gloss over his crime
Painted himself into a corner
Shady character
Couldn't brush off Holmes
Call him Matte, he's finished

Debbie Clark presented the evidence box for Retired Colourman to an attentive audience. The evidence display on the evening, and some examples of the evidence:




Left: Pictured is the plaque the Railway Arms Hotel, where Watson calledHolmes on the telephone. Right: Also pictured is the book on chess which Amberley read to hone his playing skills, and chess set. Pictured is the commercial art box from Amberley’s former company. A colourman is someone who works for a color production manufacturer.


Left: Pictured are Josiah Amberley’s calling, or visiting, cards, which he usedfor business and personal concerns. Pictured is the white pill Amberley tried to take once he had been accused of murder. Pictured are the tinted glasses worn by Mr. Barker, a privateinvestigation and a friendly Holmes’ rival. Right: Pictured are tickets for the Haymarket Theatre, which was presenting Odette, which Holmes used as a clue to determining the solution to the mystery.

Our discussion of the Retired Colourman story was lively! Before we began, I reminded the group that the occupation of colourman was a true one. A few years ago, walking in London I spied just such a business - you can see more in my blog post.

This story was one of the last written by Doyle, and has had plenty of radio adaptations, but only one television episode. We began by asking: is this a good story? There was a strong feeling of no - but pehaps it's fair to say there were issues with the tale and its plotting and believability, rather than of the writing itself. Grant said it was a 'terrible story', but with interesting features such as a competing/collaborating private detective (Barker) we all wish would have made a reappearance in future stories. Olivia really liked that this new foil was being introduced. Debbie shared that author Will Thomas has a mystery series based on Barker titled the 'Barker & Llewellyn' series - 17 novels in total have been published.

Was the claim of elopement believable? And what was the deal with Amberley having an artifical leg - it didn't seem to have any bearing on the story or its solving. Greg asked - was it believable that the phrase 'We we...' was visible in the room if Amberley was painting it?

There was quite a bit of discussion about the paint in the house (I hadn't really made the connection between a colourman and house paint), the smell of the paint, the gas that was used in the murder, and whether that gas would have had a smell. Did Amberley paint to cover up the smell of gas to those he was murdering? We thought no, because he just locked them in an gassed them. Then.... was the paint to cover up some telltale smell of the toxic gas after the fact? Well gas tends to not stick around. I assumed reading the story that it was to cover up the smell of wherever the bodies were buried in the house - but we are left believing those were tossed down an old well. So the painting of the house as a strategy isn't really clear.

Amberley taking a poison pill was a remarkable and hasty admission of guilt given that there was no direct evidence (though Holmes was clearly going to look in the well at some point!). Michelle described it as a 'flip-the-table' moment, and Greg felt that it demonstrated the forethought Amberley put into the murder.

We did recognize some possible inspiration in the story - particularly that of H.H. Holmes in Chicago in the 1890s (described in non-fiction book 'Devil in the White City'). Baring Gould says this story probably occurred in 1898. H.H. Holmes was reputed to have created sealable rooms in his hotel that he would use to gas people, then dispose of their bodies. Brent pointed out that a number of stories have clear inspirations in real-world crimes, such as the Empty House and the Royal baccarat scandal.



Our presentation was from member Olivia Millunzi (one of us! one of us!). That was probably Olivia's third presentation in four years! Olivia has been confusing people using the Canon since she dressed as Sherlock Holmes for Halloween when she was ten; the great-coat was made (by her very supportive mom) of upholstery fabric, and the deerstalker was two of her dad’s baseball caps pinned together.  Though she no longer fits in the costume, she has since become a member of Watson’s Tin Box of Baltimore, and a charter member of the Dancing Men Scourers (by-laws pending). She lives in Frederick, MD with an unconscionable number of books and a cat.

Olivia Millunzi’s presentation explored the history of Broadmoor Hospital, a high-security psychiatric hospital in England established in 1863 for people considered criminally insane. The presentation connected to the evening's story via Sherlock's comment on the guilty party: "I think his destination is more likely to be Broadmoor than the scaffold".

Olivia traced the hospital’s development, changing approaches to psychiatric care over the past two centuries, and ongoing problems with overcrowding, administration, security, and patient safety. And there was drama, with attention given to scandals involving abuse, staff misconduct, and failures of oversight including an escapee who returned after escaping succesfully three decaudes earlier. The presentation concluded with historical cases illustrating Broadmoor’s connection to notorious crimes, and changing attitudes toward mental illness and criminal responsibility. I am hopeful this presentation will evolve into an article!


Next month, we'll discuss Charles Augustus Milverton, and Andy Solberg will be telling the story of the Hound of the Baskervilles from the perspective of the dog!


The Passing Acquaintances of Arthur Conan Doyle - Part 6: Edgar Tozer

The latest Passengers' Log (PL), from the Sydney Passengers, has arrived in the mail - it's always wonderful to receive, and as alwa...