This is how Messrs. M'Clure, Phillips, and Co., of New York, advertise the American edition of "The Hound of the Baskervilles":—
It is positively Abnormal.
He will Dip Into it.
Yes ?
And then ?
Wise Man !
A place to reflect on all things Sherlockian, Holmesian, Doyleian, Mycroftian, Watsonian, and more. There will probably be an emphasis on books!
Each third Monday of the month, the Watson's Tin Box of Ellicott City scion meets - and after a virtual meeting in July we gathered on Monday August 18 for our LARGEST MEETING since COVID. It was wonderful to see so many people attend, especially on the back of over forty people the month before for our Zoom meeting.
The story of the meeting was The Empty House, or, as we called it - "Part 2".
After a traditional toast to The Woman, Liane Luini reprised a toast to Pietro Venucci. The toast was written by Paul Churchill, published in the 2008 issue of Irene's Cabinet, and I'm happy to say was first proposed at a meeting of the Red Circle of Washington, DC in 2007. In 'those days', the Red Circle met at the National Press Club (as Peter Blau, organizer of the Red Circle then and now, was a member of 'the Press'. Here is the toast:
This toast was followed by the traditional Haiku for the story was delivered by Tom Fahres:
Holmes, Watson, Lastrade
Are skulking thru dark allies
To capture Moran
Here's a Sidney Paget illustration. It's not one that relates to Sherlock, indeed it doesn't relate to any Conan Doyle story. It is, nevertheless, a Sidney Paget illustration.
It was recently sold at auction, and this was the description at auction.
PAGET, Sidney (British, 1860-1908). “Tally Ho” at the Hippodrome. [19th century - early 20th century]. ORIGINAL BLACK AND WHITE WASH DRAWING ON WINSOR & NEWTON SKETCHING BOARD. Signed at lower right corner. Captioned in pencil beneath the artwork. Sight 14 x 10’. Matted and framed under plexiglass 20 ½ x 17”. Not examined out of frame. Offered with a color print of this image (now captioned “Fox Hunting”; approximately 15 x 11”). Provenance: Purchased from a descendant of Paget in 2011. From the collection of noted Sherlockiana collector, Robert Hess.
The paper indicates that 'the editor will be glad to receive for consideration drawings and sketches of current events', though in the case of Paget it seems unlikely he was providing unsolicited submissions.
What was this "Tally Ho!"? It was in fact 'the most sensational picture ever' - a cinematograph shown at the Hippodrome.
The word 'Hippodrome' is an old word for venues that could host horse events. The Victoria & Albert Museum site has a page dedicated to the Hippodrome. It relates:
"London’s most magnificent building to mount aquatic circus was the London Hippodrome near Leicester Square, on a site bounded by Cranbourn Street, Charing Cross Road and Newport Street. Built by Edward Moss to combine hippodrome, circus and theatre, it was designed by the talented theatre architect Frank Matcham.
"The auditorium featured a stage and an arena or ring containing a tank 230 feet in circumference operated by hydraulic rams. It sank to a depth of 8 foot in about a minute and was filled with 100,000 gallons of water weighing 400 tons for spectacles
"March 1901 at The London Hippodrome saw the ‘hunting sensation’ Tally-Ho! with Albert Hengler’s hunters and plunging horses.
-----
Newspaper reviews provide some sense of scale of the "Tally Ho!" performance, and its popularity as a spectacle.
The Music Hall and Theatre Review (Friday 07 June 1901) provided a long review, which I've excerpted:
THE HIPPODROME. " TALLY Ho ! Tally Ho ! And away we go." There is a fine inspiriting note in the fox hunters' chorus that many a one will admit who never saw a fox hunt. It conjures up green country, fresh breezes, and cheery folk. Hot, breathless, sordid London is forgotten— Leicester Square was a thousand miles away from the comfortable stall in the Hippodrome from which, on Monday night, one watched the course of Reynard the Fox , or Harlequin Jack Ferrers, Sweet Kate, and the Equestrian Elopement—for there is a love story as well as a fox hunt in the new spectacular piece at the Hippodrome.
It is quite the best thing that Mr. Moss has done, from the point of view of dramatic interest, scenic illusion, and the employment of the resources—equestrian, aquatic, and so forth—of the establishment. Sixty hounds, forty horses, and a hundred and fifty people are employed in "Tally Ho ! "
{Summary of the performance, which is a play} From this point the story has to be taken for granted—it is lost in the ardour of the fox hunt. There is a vivid picture of the meet on the lawn of Oldbuck Hall, with its great gathering of typical sportsmen, to whom old English hospitality is tendered. Quickly the hounds are in full cry, and then comes the water jump ! The arena is flooded and ingeniously merged in the scenic surroundings, so that it seems like a stream into which the fox plunges, then the hounds, and thereafter the riders, every man Jack of them, the women too !
Now the audience is thrilled with interest in the progress of the hunt ; now admiring brilliant horsemanship ; now screaming with laughter at the mishaps of cockney sportsmen. Actors and actresses of distinction are employed in the narration of the story.
It appears that the show recording could be purchased also as a moving picture recording, as this full-page advertisement in 'The Showman' (Friday 19 July 1901) reveals. Yet I cannot identify in newspapers a photograph of the stage or performance:
------
Back to Paget's illustration. It does not at first glance appear to show the Hippodrome venue, but more of an idyllic village scene of the hunt entering into a stream or river, but again I can find no images of the hippodrome performance to make comparison.
Paget's work includes the phrase 'Tally Ho! at the Hippodrome' as a title inked onto the bottom of the drawing, which suggests it was created in direct response to the show. Perhaps Paget himself visited the hippodrome!
Yet close inspection the sign by the stream reveals one stating "TO BONCHURCH". Bonchurch is a small village on the Isle of Wight.
This is a short post that might be edited into a longer post later on. I've written before that my favorite Sherlock society publications are those of the Northern Musgraves (a northern-England group). I've previously posted on collecting their published Monographs (now complete), and the society also had two periodicals: the 'Musgrave Papers', and the 'Ritual' that I've slowly been working to collect.
There were fourteen issues of The Musgrave Papers from 1988-2001. Around 2001 the group became less active. As the journal evolved, each cover received a unique design, and generally speaking each issue had a them. Here are the designs:
This was going to be a relatively short post, just to 'make a point'.
Fergus Hume's "Mystery of a Hansom Cab" was a massively successful murder-mystery novel, both in Australia and the UK.
In doing some research on the story recently, I noticed a persistent statement: that Mystery of a Hansom Cab inspired Conan Doyle's creation of the Sherlock Holmes stories. Here are some examples of where that is stated:
The first mentions of Fergus Hume's book in Australia newspapers.
'Mystery of a Hansom Cab' is believed to have been written towards the end of 1885 or early 1886. The first mentions of the book are unsurprisingly in Melbourne papers, the first on 21 Oct 1886, followed by two in November.
The book is not mentioned in any newspapers in Dec 1886. In 1887 the story received only fifty mentions in newspapers (many advertisements of the book being for sale), and was published in a serialized form that year in a regional NSW paper called the 'Macleay Argus'.
All in all then, the book didn't exactly take off, and the limited early print run may account for this. In fact the next article covering the
And so to the UK, where the book must have been released The first mentions of the book are unsurprisingly in Melbourne papers, the first on 28 Nov 1887, followed by two in November.
One can imagine that Doyle may have been disappointed to have his brilliant new detective novel outsold by a colonial mystery novel. Perhaps this partially accounts for Doyle's dismissal of the 'Hansom Cab' story. He wrote to his mother on 1 March 1888, when Hansom Cab was being sold by the thousands:
"What a swindle 'The Mystery of a Hansom Cab' is. One of the weakest tales I have read, and sold by puffing."
The public didn't agree with Doyle, nor did the reviews. Hume wrote a wonderful novel, but Doyle created an enduring character. And Doyle stuck with his character, and created a phenomenon that lasted four decades. Hume's story was sensational, but did not create a character who could be serialized - multiple parties worked to get to the bottom of the scandal and murderer in Hansom Cab - it was not a story built around a detective. In fact Hume never did create a recurring character across over 100 novels.
Doyle and Hume had one more thing in common for their late 1887 mystery stories. Both sold their rights, and missed out on massive royalties in the years ahead !
--------
There is a very slight but delightful connection in the above articles. The English 'Sporting Life' article in late 1887 mentions that an advertising campaign was undertaken to sell 'Hansom Cab': "the "posting" and “sandwiching’’ our streets of coloured character portraits of the principal personages in the story —admirably designed by Mr. Matt Stretch...."
A set of those advertising posters exist - held by XXXX, and they are magnificent.
The name of the illustrator Matt Stretch might ring a bell - his name appears on the cover of the 1887 Beeton's Christmas Annual:
I've been revisiting Fergus Hume's "Mystery of a Hansom Cab". Published in 1886 - after Doyle wrote a Study in Scarlet but well before that book was published. Like Doyle, Hume couldn't have imagine the immense success - Mystery of a Hansom Cab surely outsold Study in Scarlet - and like Doyle he sold the rights for a relatively small sum, and therefore missed out on the potential riches.
Hume and Doyle's stories have another feature in common - their first editions are exceedingly rare. The Beeton's Christman Annual had perhaps 100,000 or more issued, but a few dozen exist. Hume's first edition was in 500 copies, and is considered to not exist.
I've been working on a project related to Hume, and enjoy this interview with Hume on his arrival in England. It provides an excellent first-hand summary of Hume's early career and publishing challenges, and a clear outline of the early publishing history of his sensational first novel.
While the interview is published in an Australian newspaper, it is re-printed from an English newspaper.
The Maitland Mercury and Hunter River General Advertiser
Sat 18 Aug 1888
I'm working on a new project ; actually I've been working on it for a long time and just picked it up again. In reviewing some newsp...